In a contentious tribunal, a maths teacher’s dismissal for refusing to use a student’s preferred pronouns ignites debate over inclusivity, belief, and institutional policy. Here’s the full story.
Transgender Rights
The issue of transgender rights has become a fiercely fought battle in the United Kingdom, with the current government weaponizing the issue as part of the culture war.
Wedge Issue
With no clear policy accomplishments or direction, the Conservative government has used the issue as a wedge to differentiate itself from the opposition, with little to no care given to the lives that will be affected in the process.
“TERF Island”
This top-down discrimination against trans people has led to the UK being given the moniker “TERF Island,” in reference to the Trans Exclusionary Reactionary Feminism movement, which stresses the importance of biological sex over gender identity.
Leaking Out
This discourse has, predictably, leaked out into the wider public, with the issue of trans rights becoming a hot topic up and down the country.
Employment Tribunal
This was on display recently in an employment tribunal at the Bristol Civil Justice Centre, with the dismissal of Kevin Lister, a mathematics teacher at New College Swindon.
Preferred Pronouns
Lister’s termination stemmed from his refusal to adhere to a college policy regarding a student’s preferred pronouns.
Ongoing Backlash
The whole unfortunate saga has shed light on the complexities of gender identity in educational settings in the context of the ongoing backlash against trans rights.
Gross Misconduct
Lister, a 60-year-old teacher, faced allegations of gross misconduct after declining to use the preferred name and he/him pronouns of a 17-year-old student undergoing social transitioning, identified only as student A.
Reluctance to Comply
Lister’s reluctance to comply with the students’ wishes led to his subsequent dismissal in September 2022, sparking a legal battle over claims of unfair treatment and discrimination.
“Compelled Speech”
During the tribunal, Lister argued that acquiescing to Student A’s preferred pronouns amounted to “compelled speech,” infringing upon his and other students’ beliefs.
Pressuring Educators
He contended that the college’s policy pressured educators to endorse students’ gender transitions irrespective of personal convictions, thereby overstepping the boundaries of professional obligations.
“The Demand On Me”
Lister explained his reasoning to the hearing at the Bristol Civil Justice Centre, stating, “I took issue with the demand on me to socially transition children who are unable to make an informed decision. That is the intention of the policy – to encourage children to socially transition and to push them towards transgender lobby groups.”
“Not Allowed to Question”
He continued, “Why are we not allowed to question why a student is presenting in the opposite sex? It is not the role of a maths teacher to confirm the gender transition and social transition of a student.”
Legality of College Policies
Lister raised concerns about the legality of college policies, alleging violations of the Equality Act by enforcing practices that, in his view, undermined academic integrity and disregarded dissenting perspectives.
Coercing Conformity
He posited that such policies could coerce conformity rather than foster genuine inclusivity, leading to potential clashes between institutional guidelines and individual rights.
Refuting Claims
Representing the college, Jude Shepherd refuted Lister’s claims, asserting that policy directives promoting inclusivity did not impede staff members’ freedom to hold gender-critical beliefs.
“Treating People With Respect”
Shepherd argued that Lister’s beliefs did not stop him, or other staff members with similar beliefs, from being “inclusive and treating people with respect.”
Classroom Interactions
Testimonies at the hearing revealed the peculiar way Lister navigated classroom interactions, which conflicted with his beliefs.
Resorting to Gestures
Instead of using Student A’s preferred pronouns, Lister resorted to gestures, such as merely pointing at the student.
“I Was Pointing”
Lister attempted to explain his behaviour, stating, “I gestured. Some people would say I was pointing. I didn’t want to use her dead name, but I didn’t want to assist with her social transitioning.”
Not Clear
It was not clear why Lister felt it was his responsibility as a maths teacher to decide to interfere in how one of his students wanted to be addressed.
“You Are a Girl”
Another notable exchange occurred when Student A expressed interest in participating in a girl’s math’s competition. Lister replied, “Of course, you can enter because you are a girl.”
Discomfort and Discordance
Lister’s unwillingness to endorse the student’s self-identification underscored the discomfort and discordance in the classroom environment.
“That Was a Factual Response”
When Shepard suggested that such a response was insensitive, Lister defended himself by saying, “No, that was a factual response. Student A is trying to subject me to compelled speech and the rest of the class to compelled speech.
“It Was Upsetting”
He continued, “It was upsetting for the rest of the class to be subjected to that. The rest of the class didn’t look happy – some of the students rolled their eyes.”
“Dead Name”
This incident, along with others, such as using Student A’s “dead name,” the name by which they were previously known, on the whiteboard, elicited scrutiny regarding Lister’s intentions and the ensuing impact on student well-being.
Sensitivity and Appropriateness
While Lister claimed pragmatic reasoning for his actions, questions arose about the sensitivity and appropriateness of his responses, particularly in light of Student A’s vulnerability and emotional distress.
Weaponization of Trans Rights
As the tribunal continues, the effect of the weaponization of trans rights is becoming all the more apparent, with gender-critical ideas flowing out into the country from the government.
Accommodating Diverse Perspectives
Without respect for individuals’ identities, accommodating diverse perspectives in educational settings becomes meaningless.
Individual Rights
In a society that upholds individual rights as sacrosanct, it is strange that individual rights have become an issue on which the right, in particular, takes such offence.
25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Remember the days when you could freely discuss just about anything without fear of sparking controversy? Well, those days are long gone. In today’s hyper-sensitive world, there are topics so fraught with tension that even mentioning them can lead to heated debates and hurt feelings. 25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
Ever had a car that spent more time with the mechanic than on the road? A car that turned every journey into a game of “Will we actually get there?” If so, you might just see a familiar face (or should we say, chassis) in our countdown to the most unreliable British car in history. Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
“Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
Former Home Secretary Suella Braverman has warned that Britain will become “unrecognizable,” criticizing the amount of work visas the Home Office has approved, despite only being removed from her role in November. “Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
Step into the time machine and set the dial to the 1970s, a decade of disco, bell-bottoms, and some rather questionable choices. While the ’70s gave us iconic music and groundbreaking TV, not everything from this groovy era would get a green light today. 20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
Navigating the UK university landscape is like deciphering a complex code of rankings, reviews, and reputations to uncover where you’ll not just learn, but truly flourish. Whether you’re drawn to the historic halls of Oxford or the creative buzz of Goldsmiths, finding your perfect fit is about aligning your aspirations with the unique offerings of each institution. 20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
The post “You Are a Girl” – Teacher’s Pronoun Dismissal Leads to Tribunal Over Enforcing Gender-Identity in Schools first appeared on Edge Media.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Chay_Tee.
Grant Gallacher is a seasoned writer with expertise in politics and impactful daily news. His work, deeply rooted in addressing issues that resonate with a wide audience, showcases an unwavering commitment to bringing forth the stories that matter. He is also known for satirical writing and stand up comedy.