A recent report by the think tank UK in a Changing Europe has poured cold water on Labour’s already smothered EU policy. Here’s the full story.
Don’t Mention Brexit
Labour had hoped to keep quiet on Brexit during the election campaign, but Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves had recently suggested that, if elected, Labour would attempt to refine the existing relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union.
Limited Hopes for Change
Unfortunately for those hoping for some significant reversal of Brexit, Labour would only seek to improve the UK’s strained relationship with the EU through technical adjustments and regulatory alignments.
Criticism From Think Tanks
However, UK in a Changing Europe has critiqued these measures as insufficient to mitigate the disastrous economic impacts of Brexit significantly.
“Tinkering Around the Edges”
UK in a Changing Europe described Labour’s desire for technical adjustments over structural changes to the UK-EU relationship as “tinkering around the edges of the current relationship.”
Proposed Agreements
The party’s proposed changes include agreements on mobility, veterinary standards, and security cooperation aimed at reducing red tape and improving trade with the bloc, which remains Britain’s largest trading partner.
Improving Trade Relations
Reeves told The Financial Times that Labour would “look to improve our trading relationship with Europe,” and added that the public did not vote for Brexit because “they were not happy that chemicals regulations were the same across Europe.”
Modest Economic Benefits
The economic benefits of Labour’s proposed technical adjustments are likely to be modest as, according to the report, these changes would only “sand away at the sharpest edges” of Brexit’s economic impacts, providing minimal gains in reducing trade friction.
“Tinkering Around the Edges”
The report states, “With economic growth a priority, the most obvious source of such growth will have been ruled out in the manifesto. For the moment, Starmer and his team seem content to talk in terms of tinkering around the edges of the current relationship.”
Minimal Gains Expected
It adds, “Any gains from technical improvements will be relatively minimal: useful in reducing trade frictions, but not enough to really address the continuing economic impacts of Brexit.”
Economic Costs of Brexit
The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that Brexit has already led to a 2-4% reduction in UK GDP, with a 15% decline in trade.
Limited Policy Impact
Given these substantial economic costs, the impact of Labour’s proposed policy changes appears limited.
Marginal Export Increases
Even the most ambitious proposals, such as negotiating a veterinary agreement to streamline animal product checks, are expected to yield only marginal export increases.
Challenges With the EU
One of the significant challenges Labour faces is the EU’s potential reluctance to engage in new negotiations or to prioritise UK relations.
EU’s Potential Reluctance
The UK in a Changing Europe report suggests that the EU may not be highly receptive to Labour’s proposals unless the UK offers substantial incentives, such as a mobility agreement.
Rejected Mobility Deal
The EU extended an olive branch to the UK through a youth mobility deal that allowed young Britons and Europeans to live and work in each other’s countries.
Rejection by Leaders
However, this was rejected by both Conservative leader Rishi Sunak and Labour leader Keir Starmer out of hand at the time. Similarly, Reeves recently rejected the proposal.
Long-Term Implications
John Springford, from the Centre for European Reform think-tank, stated that such a rejection would not work in Labour’s favour in the long run.
Need for Concessions
Springford stated, “If Labour proves unwilling to offer the EU any significant concessions on the movement of people, dynamic alignment with changing EU rules, and enforcement by the European Court of Justice, then the economic gains from any renegotiation will be small.”
Hard Choices Ahead
Joël Reland, a senior researcher from UK in a Changing Europe, agreed, stating, “Labour has maintained a studied silence on Brexit in this election campaign, but if elected, it will have to face up to some hard choices.”
Political Safety vs. Growth
He added, “Avoiding deals which involve alignment with the EU rules is the politically safer option, but this could well undermine its attempts to boost economic growth.”
EU’s Limited Interest
The EU has shown limited interest in revisiting the Trade and Cooperation Agreement terms, which came into effect in 2021.
Risky Trade-Offs
Labour’s EU policy reflects a series of potentially risky political and economic trade-offs. On the one hand, the party seeks to improve the UK’s economic performance through enhanced regulatory cooperation and targeted agreements.
Navigating Complex Politics
On the other hand, it must navigate the complex political landscape of Brexit, where any moves perceived as undermining UK sovereignty or reversing Brexit will likely face significant opposition from both Conservative Brexiteers and the country’s predominantly Brexit-supporting right-wing press.
Limited Economic Gains
However, this cautious approach limits the potential economic gains from improved EU relations. Without significant concessions or alignment with EU rules, Labour’s policy changes are unlikely to address the ongoing economic challenges of Brexit fully.
Impact of Election Outcome
Wanderscot
If Labour wins the upcoming election, the party’s proposals for improving the UK’s relationship with the EU may reduce some trade friction. Still, they will likely fall far short of tackling the devastating effect of Brexit on the UK economy.
Need for Radical Proposals
However, whether reports like those from UK in a Changing Europe will be enough to convince the Labour Party that more radical proposals are needed in the face of ever-present opposition to any realignment with the EU remains to be seen.
25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Remember the days when you could freely discuss just about anything without fear of sparking controversy? Well, those days are long gone. In today’s hyper-sensitive world, there are topics so fraught with tension that even mentioning them can lead to heated debates and hurt feelings. 25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
Ever had a car that spent more time with the mechanic than on the road? A car that turned every journey into a game of “Will we actually get there?” If so, you might just see a familiar face (or should we say, chassis) in our countdown to the most unreliable British car in history. Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
“Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
Former Home Secretary Suella Braverman has warned that Britain will become “unrecognizable,” criticizing the amount of work visas the Home Office has approved, despite only being removed from her role in November. “Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
Step into the time machine and set the dial to the 1970s, a decade of disco, bell-bottoms, and some rather questionable choices. While the ’70s gave us iconic music and groundbreaking TV, not everything from this groovy era would get a green light today. 20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
Navigating the UK university landscape is like deciphering a complex code of rankings, reviews, and reputations to uncover where you’ll not just learn, but truly flourish. Whether you’re drawn to the historic halls of Oxford or the creative buzz of Goldsmiths, finding your perfect fit is about aligning your aspirations with the unique offerings of each institution. 20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
The post Think Tank Warns Labour’s Brexit Fix Is Only “Tinkering Around The Edges” first appeared on Edge Media.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / Altopix.
Grant Gallacher is a seasoned writer with expertise in politics and impactful daily news. His work, deeply rooted in addressing issues that resonate with a wide audience, showcases an unwavering commitment to bringing forth the stories that matter. He is also known for satirical writing and stand up comedy.