Amid escalating tensions over immigration and human rights, some in government have sought to downplay the idea of leaving the European Convention on Human Rights. Here’s the full story.
Sustained Attack
Just days after Amnesty International released a report that savages the UK government’s sustained attack on human rights both at home and abroad, a divisive debate has begun over the UK’s membership of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
Confected Concerns
Amid confected concerns over small boat crossings, which bring a tiny number of people into the country, high-ranking officials have attempted to downplay the necessity of implementing the right-wing Conservative dream of leaving the ECHR.
Drastic Measures
Foreign Secretary David Cameron has asserted that such drastic measures are not “necessary,” despite others in his party who would love to see the UK, like human rights abusers Russia and Belarus, no longer part of the ECHR.
Small Number
The entire right-wing argument for leaving the ECHR is rooted in the difficulty of negotiating a returns agreement with France for the small number of asylum seekers and refugees who come to the UK looking for a better life.
Rwanda Plan
Under the guise of tackling people smuggling, Downing Street has launched an assault on human rights by threatening to deport small boat migrants to Rwanda to await their processing. The UK’s highest court and the ECHR have declared this policy illegal.
Thorn in the Side
Despite the UK being integral to the founding of the ECHR, with Winston Churchill being a strong proponent, the human rights court has been a frequent thorn in the side of politicians who want to trample on human rights.
Migrant Quota
The UK government attributes the difficulty of sending people back to France after they have made the perilous journey to the UK to the European Union’s insistence on the UK accepting a quota of migrants, which British authorities deemed unacceptable.
Illegal Plan
At the same time, Parliament has advanced legislation to bolster the government’s Rwanda deportation scheme, which is likely to be held up in the courts due to its illegal implementation.
“Don’t Think It’s Necessary”
Cameron told ITV’s Peston, “I don’t think it’s necessary to leave the ECHR, I don’t think that needs to happen to make this policy work.”
“Totally Different Situation”
Cameron was then asked if he’d have implemented the ‘send them back’ plan when he was Prime Minister, to which he responded, “We had a totally different situation because (we) could return people directly to France.”
“Not Possible”
He continued, “Now, I’d love that situation to be the case again, that’s the most sensible thing. People land on a beach in Kent, you take them straight back to France, you therefore break the model of the people smugglers. That’s not available at the moment. It’s simply not possible.”
Serious Ethical Considerations
The Supreme Court’s ruling against the Rwanda deportation scheme underscores the legal complexities, not to mention serious ethical considerations, at play.
Internationally Illegal
Refoulement, the act of forcing an asylum seeker back to a nation where they are likely to face prosecution, is illegal under several international treaties, including the ECHR, the UN Refugee Convention, the UN Convention Against Torture and the UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
Human Rights Act
These treaties have, in turn, been written into UK domestic law under acts such as the Human Rights Act 1998, which requires the country to comply with international standards on human rights.
National Sovereignty
However, the recent Conservative election ploy of “stopping the boats” has brought these hard-won protections into doubt, with tensions mounting between the UK’s much-vaunted national sovereignty and its international obligations.
“Not on the Table”
A government spokesperson confirmed Cameron’s statements, saying, “It is the case that such a returns agreement with the French is not possible, it’s not on the table.”
“Required Quotas”
They continued, “We would not agree to any kind of deal that required quotas in return.”
“Out of Step”
Additionally, Home Secretary James Cleverly, speaking at an event in Rome, dismissed the ECHR’s criticisms of the Rwanda bill as “out of step.”
“Moral Hazard”
Cleverly stated, “There is a real moral hazard in saying to a nation state government that it cannot manage its own borders, it cannot make decisions about who does or does not live in its own country.”
“Democratic Process”
He continued, “Because that undermines the integrity of the democratic process in which we live.”
Asylum Seekers
As the UK grapples with the difficult decision of whether asylum seekers deserve human rights and whether, in its rampant desire to reduce asylum numbers, the UK should become the first country to leave the ECHR voluntarily, the government remains steadfast in its illegal decision to send asylum seekers to Rwanda.
Breaking International Law
Whether the government so badly wants to deport people whose only crime is to come to the UK seeking a better life that they will break international law and leave the one court which oversees it remains to be seen.
25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Remember the days when you could freely discuss just about anything without fear of sparking controversy? Well, those days are long gone. In today’s hyper-sensitive world, there are topics so fraught with tension that even mentioning them can lead to heated debates and hurt feelings. 25 Things You CAN’T Talk About Anymore
Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
Ever had a car that spent more time with the mechanic than on the road? A car that turned every journey into a game of “Will we actually get there?” If so, you might just see a familiar face (or should we say, chassis) in our countdown to the most unreliable British car in history. Stranded: 15 Worst British Cars in History
“Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
Former Home Secretary Suella Braverman has warned that Britain will become “unrecognizable,” criticizing the amount of work visas the Home Office has approved, despite only being removed from her role in November. “Britain Will Become Unrecognizable” – Suella Braverman Spells Disaster for UK Amid Steep Rise in Visas Issued
20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
Step into the time machine and set the dial to the 1970s, a decade of disco, bell-bottoms, and some rather questionable choices. While the ’70s gave us iconic music and groundbreaking TV, not everything from this groovy era would get a green light today. 20 Things From the ‘70s That Are Not OK Today
20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
Navigating the UK university landscape is like deciphering a complex code of rankings, reviews, and reputations to uncover where you’ll not just learn, but truly flourish. Whether you’re drawn to the historic halls of Oxford or the creative buzz of Goldsmiths, finding your perfect fit is about aligning your aspirations with the unique offerings of each institution. 20 Best and Worst Universities in the UK
The post “A Moral Hazard” – UK Politicians Divided Over Exiting European Human Rights Convention first appeared on Edge Media.
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / christianthiel.net.
Grant Gallacher is a seasoned writer with expertise in politics and impactful daily news. His work, deeply rooted in addressing issues that resonate with a wide audience, showcases an unwavering commitment to bringing forth the stories that matter. He is also known for satirical writing and stand up comedy.